D.J. Reader was New York Giants' highest-graded player in loss vs. Saints

Oct 19, 2026 - 12:00
 0  0
D.J. Reader was New York Giants' highest-graded player in loss vs. Saints

The Giants controlled most of the opening half at MetLife and led 10-0 late in the second quarter. They did not control much of what followed.

New Orleans answered with 34 consecutive points. Jameis Winston was pulled after a second interception. J.J. McCarthy entered in the fourth quarter, led three scoring drives, and cut the deficit to 34-27 with just over two minutes left. The final fourth-and-1 from the Saints’ 14-yard line fell incomplete. The loss was New York’s first since Week 2.

Pro Football Focus has graded the tape. The late rally will draw the attention. The grades will show which snaps actually held up before the deficit became that large.

Here's a look at the highest- and lowest-graded Giants players from their Week 6 loss, courtesy of Pro Football Focus.

Top 5 offense

  • WR Malik Nabers (78.6)
  • WR Charlie Jones (75.0)
  • TE Isaiah Likely (74.7)
  • QB J.J. McCarthy (74.3)
  • OL Andrew Thomas (73.9)

Bottom 5 offense

  • QB Jameis Winston (36.3)
  • TE Thomas Fidone II (41.3)
  • OL Francis Mauigoa (44.8)
  • WR Darnell Mooney (48.0)
  • OL Bryan Hudson (48.1)

Top 5 defense

  • DT D.J. Reader (89.2)
  • S Ar'Darius Washington (81.4)
  • S Jason Pinnock (78.1)
  • LB Abdul Carter (73.6)
  • LB Kayvon Thibodeaux (73.5)

Bottom 5 defense

  • LB Trace Ford (39.6)
  • DT Bobby Jamison-Travis (40.4)
  • CB Nic Jones (44.7)
  • CB Dru Phillips (49.5)
  • LB Jihad Ward (52.9)

Top 5 special teams

  • LB Arvell Reese (74.6)
  • LB Malik Harrison (74.5)
  • LB Trace Ford (72.4)
  • S Ar'Darius Washington (67.5)
  • WR Malachi Fields (66.4)

Bottom 5 special teams

  • TE Chris Manhertz (30.0)
  • TE Thomas Fidone II (32.8)
  • WR Charlie Jones (47.7)
  • LB Micah McFadden (54.8)
  • DB Elijah Campbell (55.2)

Other notable player grades

  • OL Marcus Mbow (56.1)
  • OL Jon Runyan Jr. (55.9)
  • WR Malachi Fields (55.1)
  • RB Najee Harris (51.4)
  • CB Greg Newsome II (71.5)
  • LB Arvell Reese (69.2)
  • S Jevon Holland (59.5)
  • CB Deonte Banks (56.8)

This article originally appeared on Giants Wire: D.J. Reader was New York Giants' highest-graded player in loss vs. Saints

What's Your Reaction?

Like Like 0
Dislike Dislike 0
Love Love 0
Funny Funny 0
Angry Angry 0
Sad Sad 0
Wow Wow 0